Part one
A coin, and a problem.
Suppose you have an edge. A small one, but real. You win 53 percent of your bets. Each bet returns plus or minus one unit. The remaining 47 percent you lose. How much of your capital should you risk on the next wager.
The naive answer is, as much as you can afford to lose. The textbook answer is the Kelly criterion, which we will arrive at in part four. The interesting answer, the one this essay defends, is that almost nobody applies either correctly. Most practitioners use a tool called a stop loss, set at a level that feels safe, and treat that level as if it were a guard rail. It is not a guard rail. It is a permeable membrane that the price keeps pushing through, and the tighter you set it, the more often it will be touched.
To see why, we start as simply as possible. A single coin. A running total. A line.
Total 0 · Flips 0
Press Flip once to add a coin. Auto flip adds twenty per second. Notice how the line drifts up over time when the probability favours you, but spends long stretches below its previous peak.
This is the central observation of the essay. A process with a positive expectation still spends most of its life below its previous high. That gap between the running maximum and the present value is called the drawdown. Drawdowns are the price of the edge. They are not a malfunction, they are the way the edge arrives.